Public good or personal freedom? It’s an age-old debate

By:

“The more things change, the more they remain the same.” That quip was made by an official in a diocese some distance geographically from Our Sunday Visitor when he heard about the firestorm ignited decades ago in his diocese when uniforms were mandated for parochial school students.

Presently, he is hearing strong opinions as his diocese forms a policy about wearing masks in its schools.

An elderly priest told him about the battle over school uniforms that took place 60 years ago.

This was the plan. Some nameless authority in the ivory tower that was the diocesan chancery would decide what every parochial school student wore. If parents, or the student, selected anything else, the child had to exit the school. Talk about laying down the law.

One pastor, much respected in the community at the time, detested the plan, insisting that requiring any uniform was practically and philosophically just plain wrong. He argued that uniforms forced parents to spend hard earned money. Wearing uniforms, in his view, robbed each child of his or her individuality. He had been a seminarian in Rome before World War II, watching fascism overtake Italy and national socialism swallow Germany.

He saw heavy-handed orders from on high belittle parental responsibility, rights and personal dignity. No individuality. Only the state. Follow the leader. Keep quiet. Or else. He heard Pope Pius XI’s protests.

Others defended uniforms as best for all, less expensive, bonding, levelling, sensible, community-building, avoiding vanity or glorifying one’s material advantage over another. They won the argument.

American life historically has involved balancing personal preference against the overall good.

Many publicly funded services, conscription in times of war, fire and police protection, health departments, restaurant inspections, water purification, bridges, tunnels, levees and firewalls, snow removal, streets and highways, and schools developed — few without opposition or at least questions.

A century ago, automobiles were becoming numerous and popular. People drove their cars into other cars at intersections. They drove cars so fast that, losing control, they hit something, somebody, or hurt themselves.

Politicians came up with traffic lights and signs, speed limits and, upsetting some people, drivers had to pay for, and possess, government-issued driver’s licenses to operate a vehicle on any public thoroughfare.

Some authority high on a hill decided that the government had to know how many vehicles were in operation and if vehicles met certain standards, again set by the government. They required license plates for every vehicle. People had to pay the government for the plates — more, probably much more, than what producing the plates cost. Otherwise, the government issued no plates.

Opponents said that this is a free country. Any citizen has the right to move himself or herself by whatever vehicle is chosen, on any public roadway, built, owned and maintained at public expense, with funds secured by mandatory taxation! The vast network of roads built and maintained at public expense recalls disputes in days past.

Why should a landowner on Main Street pay taxes to pave Broad Street? Property owners should be responsible for public roadways adjacent to their land! Toll roads were popular. Travelers should pay for the thoroughfares that they used.

States set speed limits, but it was controversial. Some people insisted that drivers are the best judges of how fast they should drive. They know heavy traffic, curves and obstacles when they see them!

Driver’s licenses, speed limits, stop signs, traffic lights, one-way streets and license plates were invented to safeguard travel and travelers. Now taken for granted, they were adopted, always, in what proven experts perceived to be in the best interests of all.

Some are debating the need for masks, in good faith. People are asked to wear masks for the public good. Others deny the need. It boils down to the same old questions: Is serving the public well-being greater a reason for action than individual thoughts about masks, and who decides what is best?

This article comes to you from Our Sunday Visitor courtesy of your parish or diocese.

 

Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


Recent

Public good or personal freedom? It’s an age-old debate

Monday, September 20, 2021
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion “The more things change, the more they remain the same.” That quip was made by an official in a diocese some... Read More

Opening the Word: Jealousy and ambition: The root of sin

Friday, September 17, 2021
By: Timothy P. O'Malley “Where jealousy and selfish ambition exist, there is disorder and every foul practice” (Jas 3:16). St.... Read More

The greatest Catholic novel of all time? It might be a 100-year-old Norwegian classic

Wednesday, September 15, 2021
By: Russell Shaw If you think a novel set in 14th-century Norway has to be dull, think again. Sigrid Undset’s Kristin... Read More

St. Peter Claver: A patron for race relations

Monday, September 13, 2021
By: Derek Rotty We stand in a moment of American history that calls for a new patron saint in race relations. In recent months and years, we have... Read More

Opening the Word: The hidden Messiah

Friday, September 10, 2021
By: Timothy P. O'Malley “‘But who do you say that I am?'” (Mk 8:29). Jesus asks this question to the disciples near the... Read More

Christian, go home

Wednesday, September 8, 2021
By: David Mills She was peeved. A friend had come across a quote from a “motivational speaker.” “There are too many people who... Read More

The short history of Catholicism in Afghanistan

Monday, September 6, 2021
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion The news is flooded with reports about the departure of American troops from Afghanistan. Fingers are being pointed,... Read More

Opening the Word: The challenge of James

Friday, September 3, 2021
By: Timothy P. O'Malley James speaks directly — too directly for us, who perhaps like to soften the claims of the Gospel. “My brothers... Read More

Hypocrisy in the Church is ‘detestable,’ pope says at audience

Wednesday, September 1, 2021
By: Carol Glatz VATICAN CITY (CNS) — Hypocrites are afraid of the truth, fearful of who they really are and incapable of truly loving, Pope... Read More

Tips for parents looking to pass on the Faith

Monday, August 30, 2021
By: Russell Shaw It’s hard to imagine that anyone who ever raised children found it an entirely easy job. Challenging, exciting, often... Read More